Freon vs Ammonia Refrigerant in Ice Making Industry

In the ice industry, refrigerant selection plays a critical role in ensuring efficient and environmentally friendly operations. Two commonly used refrigerants are fluorocarbons (commonly known as Freon) and ammonia. While both serve a cooling purpose, they have significant differences in performance, environmental impact, and safety. Below we will conduct an in-depth comparative analysis of these two refrigerants:

Aspect Freon Refrigerant Ammonia Refrigerant
Impact on the environment High ozone depletion. Environmentally friendly, no ozone layer depletion potential.
Global Warming Potential (GWP) High global warming potential increases climate change. Low GWP and minimal impact on global warming.
Efficiency Thermodynamically less efficient compared to ammonia.Thermodynamically less efficient compared to ammonia. High thermodynamic efficiency brings potential energy savings and provides excellent cooling performance.
Safety Generally non-toxic and non-flammable. High concentrations can be harmful, flammable and require careful handling and monitoring.
Cost Usually more expensive due to regulations and production costs. Reduced availability. Often more cost-effective due to availability and simpler production processes.
Maintenance Maintenance is easier and less expensive. Maintenance is more stringent and may be more costly due to safety concerns.

In terms of environmental impact, ammonia refrigerant is the clear winner as it has negligible impact on ozone depletion and has low global warming potential. However, safety concerns require careful handling. Freon refrigerants, on the other hand, are easier to handle but pose serious environmental problems.

In terms of efficiency and performance, ammonia refrigerants surpass Freon refrigerants with superior cooling capabilities, making them ideal for large-scale industrial ice-making operations.

Despite the many advantages of ammonia refrigerants, Freon refrigerants remain superior in applications where safety and ease of handling are critical.

Freon for ice machine

In ice machine applications, Freon refrigerants are mainly used in smaller commercial and household ice machines. For example, flake ice machine, cube ice machine, block ice machine, plate ice machine, tube ice machine, etc. These refrigerants are suitable for direct evaporative air conditioning systems, which are safer and easier to maintain. Some home ice machines, especially older models, may also use Freon refrigerant.

Ammonia refrigerant in ice making machine

Ammonia refrigerants are often used where large-scale refrigeration is required, such as in the food processing and seafood processing industries, due to their efficiency and ability to operate at low temperatures. In addition, ammonia has been widely used in industrial refrigeration applications due to its environmental protection and high energy efficiency. Ammonia refrigeration systems are also found in commercial ice plants, where large quantities of ice are produced and distributed to restaurants, supermarkets, and other businesses.

Both Freon refrigerants and ammonia refrigerants can be used in various ice machines, and natural refrigerants are also gradually emerging, such as carbon dioxide (CO2) refrigerants in ice machines.

In conclusion, both Freon refrigerants and ammonia refrigerants play an important role in the ice making industry. As the industry continues to innovate, we expect further advancements in refrigerant technology, delivering high performance and sustainability.

If you are looking for a suitable ice making machine for your ice making industry, you are welcome to contact us, whether it is a high-efficiency ammonia ice making system, a safe Freon ice making system, or a naturally refrigerated CO₂ ice making system, Grant Ice System can provide you with high-quality ice machines.



Contact us

Get Social

Send An Enquiry

Grant Ice Systems relies on the top quality products, impeccable product service, reasonable price, excellent credibility and a good reputation to gain many customer’s approval, we believe that Grant Ice Systems will be your idea choice.